skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Only had the key lime pie. It was good. Definitely a former pizza hut building.
Benjamin Urness via google.com - Apr 10, 2021
Good dining experience.!!
Lisa Johnson via google.com - Apr 10, 2021
Very good food, very good service A+ ... read more
Michael Haley via google.com - Apr 10, 2021
Great food and all that bragging about the key lime pie is no joke. Really glad we stopped! The alligator bites were really tasty too!
Al V via google.com - Apr 9, 2021
Excellent! My daughter and I enjoyed everything we ate. Nice atmosphere and wonderful service. Great job Mrs. Mac's Kitchen.
Tonia Byrf via google.com - Apr 9, 2021
Very good food. Great portion size for the money.
Crystal Traylor via google.com - Apr 8, 2021
Delicious food! Lots of choices on the menu. Try the Keylime chill! Oh and onions rings are out of this world!
Carrie Trinidad via google.com - Apr 8, 2021
We came for the Alligator bites. İ got the seafood platter. The fish was excellent. Rum punch was very strong. Our server was incredible. Out door seating was nice and spaced out. The whole island is only half a mile wide so everything is close enough to the road that you can hear the passing vehicles.
Selena Gibb via google.com - Apr 6, 2021
This place never disappoints. The service is great, as.is the food. Definitely one of our favorites, and it's family friendly too.
Annaliese Foster via google.com - Apr 6, 2021
Great experience. Kids liked the mini corn dogs and alligator bites. My husband had a burger and I g
Great experience. Kids liked the mini corn dogs and alligator bites. My husband had a burger and I got the special of the snapper stuffed with Greek salad - so unusual and creative. This was also our favorite Key Lime pie of the trip too.
Passport279558 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 4, 2021
Food was delicious! Chili is really good! Grilled hogfish sandwich was delicious as was the fish and shrimp basket. The wait was short but the hostess sat others in front of us that arrived after us. There was some drama between the hostess and the manager. Waitress was nice, but there was some serious lag between ordering and ... read more
JJ Bechtel via google.com - Apr 3, 2021
Nice atmosphere and a lot of things to choose from. Me and my boyfriend thought our meals we ok. The chili and hot wings were really good. I got sauteed yellowfin snapper and my boyfriend got the surf and turf. We both ate about half our meals. His lobster was kind of chewy and my fish was just a different flavoring.
Nicole Szynborski via google.com - Apr 2, 2021
Great Key lime pie! Went here because of how highly rated it was and wasn't disappointed!
Daniel Brown via google.com - Apr 2, 2021
Kids were so happy with the Key LIme Pie they bought, extra bonus was the whip cream they sold them
Kids were so happy with the Key LIme Pie they bought, extra bonus was the whip cream they sold them to go with it. Best crust!
Tracie121674 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 2, 2021
Good ... read more
AC jenkins via google.com - Apr 1, 2021
Key lime pie, awesome ... read more
Ray Seigler via google.com - Apr 1, 2021
Great Food & Service!
Catherine Smith via google.com - Apr 1, 2021
Really fresh food, fast and friendly service. Clean with a really fun vibe.
Carrie Glad via google.com - Apr 1, 2021
Loved it ... read more
Monte Ellis via google.com - Mar 29, 2021
Eight of us ate there, and we pretty much got half the menu. The alligator was great - I wish I had
Eight of us ate there, and we pretty much got half the menu. The alligator was great - I wish I had a liter of that hot sauce.
Peter F via tripadvisor.com - Mar 29, 2021
Great food and service! A must when in the keys.
Kind Nugz via google.com - Mar 28, 2021
Best time ever. Worth the stop.
Gina Jones via google.com - Mar 28, 2021
This was such an amazing place, Leticia was the best, she gave my dog and my brother's dog a treatment as if they would have been hers. We are definitely coming back because the food and the attention were something completely out of this world ... read more
Right Rudder via google.com - Mar 27, 2021
Great service, awesome selection of really fresh and good food. Key lime pie is fabulous ... read more
Lisa Childress via google.com - Mar 26, 2021
Always a tradition when going to the keys! The Absolute BEST key lime pie. Hands down 👐 👇 ... read more
Jared Vanore via google.com - Mar 25, 2021
Awesome food and service.
Aaron Lyle via google.com - Mar 25, 2021
A perfect translation of my thoughts about this restaurant dont exist. Well at least, not in this language. But if you must know, well picture this: the sun is setting and the moon is setting also and you're there in a gazebo, and then God decends from heaven and gives you a million dollars. You take that feeling, and put it onto a d ... read more
Kyle Leach via google.com - Mar 24, 2021
Excellent. Will always stop on our way ... read more
Omer Pierce via google.com - Mar 24, 2021
The food was delicious and good portions. We only had soup and appetizers and salad but were completely satisfied. Drinks were very good and served promptly. The decor was nice. It is a place to visit when in Key Largo.
Lola Higgins via google.com - Mar 24, 2021
EXCELLENT fresh food..OUTSTANSING service ... read more
s Moskowitz via google.com - Mar 23, 2021
Came here twice this week. Once for dinner and once for a quick bite before headed to the airport home. Both times were wonderful. Food was delicious, staff was friendly, attentive and made great suggestions. Establishment is clean and super cute inside with a cozy beach vibe. The bar top is incredible. Want to make the same at home ... read more
Brian Culver-Grossmith via google.com - Mar 22, 2021
Great food, great service, 5 stars not enough.
bob finch via google.com - Mar 22, 2021
Good food. Great key lime pie!
Rick K via google.com - Mar 22, 2021
The jerk chicken is off the hook. My wife's porterhouse was undercooked. The crab cakes were awesome
The jerk chicken is off the hook. My wife's porterhouse was undercooked. The crab cakes were awesome. Chili cheese fries were also decent. Maybe a bit overpriced but overall not a bad experience.
O9022XAscottg via tripadvisor.com - Mar 21, 2021
We stopped in for dinner and were seated quickly. My son has Autism and this place is busy but they
We stopped in for dinner and were seated quickly. My son has Autism and this place is busy but they took the time to get us a booth (which helps him). The staff were excellent, not a single mistake with our order and by far the fastest food in the keys. We were very satisfied with this place and reasonable too. We can't say enough go ... read more
Explore798556 via tripadvisor.com - Mar 21, 2021
Fantastic food! Stopped here looking for some food and was pleasantly surprised of how good it was. I got the Fish and Shrimp basket and it was fantastic. Then, for dessert key lime pie and it was FANTASTIC! Great restaurant, definitely recommend.
Zachary Plett via google.com - Mar 19, 2021
This is home cooking at its best!!! Awesome Lobster Thermidor and great service great margaritas👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 ... read more
Andres Morgado via google.com - Mar 19, 2021
Drove by a couple of the other highly rated diners in Key Largo and wasn’t impressed. This place had
Drove by a couple of the other highly rated diners in Key Largo and wasn’t impressed. This place had a good crowd and plenty of parking. Was very impressed at the cleanliness of the place and friendliness of the staff. They have a great menu that includes sea food and land food. You should be able to find multiple good options for an ... read more
Cassel12 via tripadvisor.com - Mar 19, 2021
Very busy for lunch and parking was not good. Had to park at the church across the street. I had the
Very busy for lunch and parking was not good. Had to park at the church across the street. I had the hogfish grilled sandwich was excellent. The a piece of key lime pie to finish the meal. Our entire lunch was excellent. Get there early it gets busy ... read more
Chino0365 via tripadvisor.com - Mar 19, 2021
The manager Liz and our server Valerie were amazing. The food and service was perfect. Felt very at home. Best key lime pie in all of Florida ... read more
Michelle Boutselis via google.com - Mar 18, 2021
Excellent food and service. Not the typical keys restaurant. Will return to try other dishes.
Greg Lorentz via google.com - Mar 18, 2021
Best food we had in the Keys. We stayed for a bit over a week, down near Key West. We ate as Mrs. Mac's on the way down and again on the way up. In between we at at several places, all really good. However none were as good as this place. The crab cakes are wonderful as is their baskets. Great for the whole family.
Clint Eschberger via google.com - Mar 18, 2021
Awesome place, must stop! Food was amazing and affordable. Definitely get a piece of keylime pie! Great place to stop and get good food from friendly and attentive staff.
Britt N via google.com - Mar 17, 2021
Everything was delicious! Crab cakes, fish tacos, conch chowder, muddled margarita and of course the key lime pie!! I definitely recommend. We loved our server, Melissa too!
Anna M via google.com - Mar 15, 2021
Everything in this place is delicious. The key lime pie is the best. We take a couple home with us each time.
Andrea Trapani via google.com - Mar 15, 2021
The coconut shrimp was excellent. My daughter loved the ribeye. The fries were not my favorite. But the key lime pie is probably the best I've had since I've been here.
Mandy Reynolds via google.com - Mar 15, 2021
Great spot to grab a bite to eat!
Tommy Pickles via google.com - Mar 15, 2021
Food and people great.
Marc Hall via google.com - Mar 15, 2021
We ate here twice - first was breakfast - that experience was awesome. Went back a few days later fo
We ate here twice - first was breakfast - that experience was awesome. Went back a few days later for dinner service was great - food was good - band could have used a little more practice.
kimberlymF5407JP via tripadvisor.com - Mar 14, 2021
Great food, and the best key lime pie!
Dawn Wright via google.com - Mar 13, 2021
I got the chocolate cake and I was happy they added chocolates syrup because it was a little dry. The atmosphere was great. Loved all the fish decorations and the floor of painted water.
ellen segal-smith via google.com - Mar 12, 2021
Went for dessert. Key Lime pie and chocolate cake. Very good Reasonable pricing.
Paul Smith via google.com - Mar 12, 2021
Very good! Pricey but good, first time I've ever had hogfish and it was great!
Cierra Bowman via google.com - Mar 12, 2021
Try the Sauted hogfish with lemon butter ... read more
Sonya Stewart via google.com - Mar 8, 2021
This was our first place to eat dinner for our Spring break trip to the Keys. Party of 8 including 4 kids and 4 adults. Service was excellent. Food came quickly and was delicious. Kids all ordered kids meals , typical American bar/restaurant fare. Adults had tuna , fried seafood platter, steak & lobster. All excellent . The cherry on ... read more
Lea Bombard via google.com - Mar 8, 2021
Great konk chowder and blackened mahi mahi sandwich. Food is always very good ... read more
SCSU89 via google.com - Mar 7, 2021
Really really good food, great service food came out quickly and hot!
Steve Fitzgerald via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
The food and service was fantastic.
Diane G via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
The food is amazing. We ate at some other VERY popular place on the island and we're extremely disappointed in the microwaved food and terrible service but Mrs. Mac's was a huge turn around. We enjoyed everything we ordered thoroughly, even the coctails were very good and the prices were even better. 10/10 would recommend!!
Joshua Hart via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Wow a great stop for very good food and to experience a little piece of a bygone Florida. The restaurant is uniquely decorated in a way that reminds me of the Florida of the past -complete with some shadow-box tables that highlight the sunshine State’s attributes. The waitstaff was very friendly and service was excellent. The price ... read more
Julie via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Excellent food, excellent service, warm and friendly staff.
Sherry Joseph via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
First night here on the family vacation and we chose this place. Have never been to the Keys before... sure am glad. The food was amazing. Wait staff was super courteous. And the key lime pie... whoa. Just awesome. Highly recommend.
Drew Bombard via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
The food at this and the original Mrs. Mac's is fabulous. I have been in the Keys six days and have had their superfishwhich sandwich twice with sweet potato fries. For me, it is the best fish sandwich. You can either get it grilled, fried or blackened. Anything they cook is excellent.
Terry Nicholson via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Try the lobster taco.
Sharon Reber via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Lots of choice on the menu for seafood and non seafood lovers. They key lime pie was delicious.
Google Account via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Great Food, Great service!
Greg Winstead via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Been there three times, the service is excellent. The food..omg!! Delicious, my compliments to the chef. I come from Orlando and already told my friend this is the place for us to eat out.
Millie Rivera via google.com - Mar 6, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire